Generous, (strong) mojito.
Plate of shrimp cooked in coconut milk and spices, cilantro rice and fried plantains.
The best flan and homemade caramel sauce I've had in ages.
All this, plus the company of a sweet friend.
If you are local, give Antigua in West Allis a try. Latin food from Mexico, Spain and Latin America. But first, check out Restaurant.com for a gift certificate ($25 certificate for $10, which often becomes $8 or as low as $2 close to the end of the month) to use on both food and drink.